
Originally Posted by
Lewis
The Many Saints of Newark is worth a watch, but I'm not sure it was worth making. There were a couple of nice references for the fans, but otherwise it was just an average sort of film. The woman who played Livia was probably the best thing about it, but the lad doing young Silvio should never work again (then again actual Silvio was fucking terrible).
You're right about the lad who plays Silvio, he's fucking terrible. Way over the top. What is going on with the timeline there too? Silvio and Pussy are not that much older than Tony. It's specifically mentioned in the show a few times that they all came up together. Especially Pussy, they're like childhood best friends or something.
But here they're full initiated in the mafia when Tony is still a little kid, even before the time jump. It's like they just shoehorned that in to have an excuse to get some young actors to do Silvio and Pussy impressions. Stuff like that annoys me. Paulie, fair enough. He was good too.
Livia was fantastic. I would watch an entire spin-off series of Vera Farmiga just playing Livia. She nailed it and was by far the best thing about it.
I didn't like the revelation of:
Toggle Spoiler
Junior having Dickie killed. I don't think Junior would do that. It changes the basis of the Tony and Junior relationship too much too. That's one of the central and most important relationships of the entire show, you can't just retcon it with all that new subtext. I know Tony doesn't know, but still. It was just an unnecessary twist I think. Corey Stohl as Junior was quite good though.
I sound like I'm just having a massive go at it, but it was fine overall I suppose, just nothing spectacular. It seems to be heavily leaning into the idea of a sequel at the end. At least that was my take on it. I would be really surprised if they do nothing else with Gandolfini's son as a younger Tony. Apparently David Chase has just signed some new deal with HBO too, which would also point towards that.