Can confirm the virgin death is instant and ends the day. Even if someone was on the block with 100% of the vote, if someone else nominated the virgin and died, it would supersede it.
Can confirm the virgin death is instant and ends the day. Even if someone was on the block with 100% of the vote, if someone else nominated the virgin and died, it would supersede it.
Also, if you are the virgin P3 I seriously can't believe we've got this far into the game without someone nominating you. I mean, it's usually the first port of call after Mahow in werewolf games.
SvN still has to be the Saint to meet the quota for the Baron. So I'd be the guilty party.Originally Posted by niko_cee
There are obviously levels of D chess I'm not getting here, but how is a villager suicide bombing themselves, followed by presumably another villager (you?) being killed in the night going to help exactly?
So someone needs to now nominate P_3 in order to verify the Virgin claim and I think it either needs to be Niko or SvN.
If Niko is to be believed as the Slayer, he is now useless having shot his shot and we know Mahow is not the Demon. However I think Mahow is the worst person to have chosen of those alive.
We could really do with avoiding a final day scenario where it's the Imp and 2 people who can't be nominated(Saint and Virgin) without bad things happening.
SvN going on the grenade helps stop that scenario, clears himself from any doubt(not that I have much) and clears P_3 at the same time. Thomma gets new information albeit maybe drunken and you then kill the fuck out of Niko
A fool proof plan....
If only The Saint wasn't an outsider.
Yeah hurry up and get to murdering so I can sleep
Yeah, I nominate P3, he's a lying shit and is trying to sow seeds of discontent among hard working honest villagers.
So what is the best course of action here?
Edit: Didn't see the Niko post.
@P_3 your defense is needed
It will just be you, Thommo and SvN left. Thommo will then know, with Mahow confirmed Librarian, that SvN is safe and you must the Imp. And SvN will know that, with Mahow confirmed Librarian, that Thommo is the Drunk Empath and you must be the Imp.
But... if you are the Virgin he should be dead already and it should be night.
Someone is lying here.
I don't know if that was the defense, if he wants to make another one, so be it.... but ok:
Voting is open on P_3
Once the living has voted I'll leave voting open for another half an hour (on every vote going forward) for Dead Votes. There are only a few dead votes available at the moment from @Baz @Manc @Boydy and @Gray Fox so they can also just vote No if they want to speed us up.
Unless Niko is a baddie?
My defence: I'm the Virgin. Niko is not the Slayer which he has claimed therefore he didn't die. He is the big bad.
No for me. Obviously.
3 needed to execute today as there are 5 players alive.
Just to test what happens:
I would like to slay Niko with my Slayer ability.
The lack of reaction when Niko failed to kill Mahow was odd thinking about it. I do wonder if all 3 baddies are still kicking about. Niko smells funny to me right now. SvN coincidently absent when needed again too.
Not sure P3 is the right choice here at all... but I can't vote.
So niko's a baddie then, surely.
I'm a twit
There’s at most 2 bads left. If there were 3 the game would be over.
We must now choose if Niko is a bad and therefore immune, P3 is lying or worst case, both.
Yes for me.
Reasoning is thus. Why given the reveal of his role yesterday, would the demon not kill P3, but instead someone who's role was over? Like, the least good person you could probably kill in the circumstances?
Or P_3 is lying.
lol
What a double bluff.
P_3 has claimed Slayer and shot Niko....
Toggle Spoiler
Either you or Niko are.
I'm so fucking lost now.
Not strictly true. In a world where 3 bads are still left you could kill 1 today and get to Final 3 tomorrow.
If you're the slayer and Mahow is the librarian, he should be dead. P3 was right on that and.... silence. Then HE gets nominated?
Niko and Mahow are suss as fuck. P3 is a good guy.
AND if Niko is a good guy and P3 is the virgin, Niko should be dead for nominating him?
Niko is so fucking suss.
No, you've lost me. Why should Mahow be dead on those facts?
What?
If Niko is the slayer I'd only be dead if I was the demon.
The Slayer can only kill the demon. If Niko is the Slayer and Mahow is the Librarian the slayer shot would fail.
It's important to note that as Storyteller I'm obliged to play along with any and all bluffs. Hypothetically in a game with no Slayer, if all the players came out on Day 1 and said they were the Slayer and shot someone, I'd have to confirm each and every time that nothing happened.
Damn it.
No on P_3
So I'm going to choose to follow and explain the info to get to my vote.
My info is that either Mahow or Baz is the Baron. If the Baron is in play we would have 3 outsiders. The Recluse and the Saint came forward on day one. The usual outsider count is 1. The only other role that potentially affects the outsider count in this script is the Spy, but I don't think game 1 we would be handed a Baron and a Spy.
I didn't reveal my info to anyone but Mahow came forward with his claim of Librarian seeing a Drunk. This confirms my own information. This is the only thing I am sure cannot be incorrect in this game. If you believe me to be good/evil, Mahow must be the same. The Demon could not bluff that without it being easily ruled out.
Mahow saw the drunk as being either Baz or Thomma. As we know Baz must be the Baron, Thomma must be the drunk and therefore his gamelong info of a 1 reading must be wrong. This then means P3 and SvN are in the clear. The only other person left in the game is Niko and he's the odd one out.
I vote no.
You really are sleep deprived.
You're dead, are you really using your ghost vote on this?
A no is not a Ghost Vote.
Well I'm putting my hand down so it's not really a vote.
I'm also tired.
@Sir Andy Mahowry and @thommo left to vote.
Technically you're supposed to vote the next time you post so sort it out Mahow.
Apologies.
I'll vote no.
I think they might both be lying but I think Niko is more likely to be the imp.
I said earlier I think niko is more likely to be the Imp, hiding behind the Slayer bluff. I'm voting no.
Nicely coordinated fellas
No private conversations allowed during nomination phase, "Saint".
I think it's unlikely you're going to get 2 of the 3 remaining Ghost Votes (given that Gray Fox has voted no) within half an hour so with the hope of getting through this phase this night I will say that
1 vote is not enough and P_3 is safe for today.
Nominations are open.
P_3 says he's the virgin.
niko_cee is still alive, and therefore a baddie, surely?
I'm a twit
We kill Niko today and if the game continues, P3 tomorrow?
P_3 could be lying as well.P_3 says he's the virgin.
niko_cee is still alive, and therefore a baddie, surely?
They could even both by lying to try and play us.
Anyway, I nominate Niko.
Reason being I think he's most likely to be the imp.
Reply With Quote
