Cheers, thommo. Are we able to amend votes? If so put me down for a yes.
Printable View
Cheers, thommo. Are we able to amend votes? If so put me down for a yes.
Offy's actions make more sense if he is just the chef than if he has an ongoing role. I mean, asking to die and wanting the game sped up would be a pretty risky gambit if he was a bad guy, no?
No to killing him.
You can. Technically @Gray Fox is still in the "Hot Seat" having nominated but not yet voted.
Still missing votes from @Sir Andy Mahowry @P_3, @Offshore Toon and @Niko Cee as well as him.
4-2 currently.
Obviously posted that at the same time as Niko. 4-3 then.
No for Offshore.
I'm slowly coming around to thinking that Mahow is lying rather than Spikey. If he's the Librarian, I demand to know the two people who came up as a possible Drunk. He's insinuated Offshore but kept the other one quiet. :sherlock:
I'm still keeping the names to myself for now. I haven't had a chance to talk to many people yet and I'd like to try and figure out which one of the two is the drunk first before revealing it to the town.Quote:
Originally Posted by P_3
It's a bit rich asking me to divulge all my info to you when you've given me absolutely nothing.
It's a yes to the Offshore vote from me.
Yes. Let’s get murdering.
One thing that they did on that video was ask if the outsiders wanted to reveal themselves.
Who has claimed to be a recluse so far? Have we any butler cucks?
Spikey has claimed recluse and I see a drunk.Quote:
Originally Posted by Baz
This means 2 outsiders which can't happen. We should either have 1 or there is a Baron in play and we have 3. No one is coming forward as a third though.
I am the recluse.
Not strictly true. I've narrowed down what my role is for you quite a bit.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sir Andy Mahowry
Offshore Toon has reached 6 votes.
Technically he still needs to vote on himself to determine his final total. As he said he wanted to die I can't just assume it's a no.
However, I will allow time for more nominations if someone feels strongly we should be killing someone else, or wants to try and engineer a tie to ensure no deaths.
I'll probably give 2 hours or so for this and if we don't hear anything, I'll push on to Night 2 at 2pm with a view to starting the next vote phase this evening, maybe a bit later to give more time for PMs after work etc.
Similarly if those who can still nominate and haven't expressed their desire not to nominate want to rule themselves out of nominating we can get cracking.
@Offshore Toon please vote on yourself when you can.
Sorry, been out this morning.
I vote yes.
Incredible.
I think it's unlikely you're going to match/beat 7 votes... but there's 6 minutes left if anyone wants to raise any last minute objections to moving on.
It's been a tough couple of years for Chefs. First Covid closes their restaurants, now the Devil has come to town. Poor Offy. Don't do it lad. We can talk about this. We'll get you help. #EatOutToHelpOut
Offshore Toon has been executed and dies.
The game continues. It is Night.
As a reminder for Offshore, he can continue to play as normal, but he can no longer nominate and he can only vote Yes once for the rest of the game. In all other votes his vote will default to No.
What happens now?
I'll get back to you once I receive choices from everyone who needs to make them.
Hmm I thought that might be more enlightening.
To all the good people left, you know what to do. The low numbers mean Mahow's #TeamDiscord will able to defend him easily unless you get yourselves together.
How so?Quote:
Originally Posted by Offshore Toon
I am The Saint.
Is that a third outsider claim then?
Despite the game suggesting there is only 1 in the gameboard thing? That's the light blue fella right?
For what it's worth, I waited until now to mention it because I wasn't sure if being killed by the Imp counted as "being executed", but I know understand that it's in everyone's interests if I'm open about it.
I think I'm going to allow conversation while I await confirmation on the night time activities this time, in the hope of speeding the game up and allowing a nomination phase tonight. Going forward (As in from Night 3 onwards) though there shouldn't be any posts or conversations at night. Those who wake in the night always have the option of sending me their choices in advance if they can.
I may have explained badly when conversations are allowed, so that's on me. But yea, conversations should be happening during the day both publicly and privately, and then once nominations open everything should be public.
Interesting developments.
I dunno. I'm just waiting for this game to actually become a game.Quote:
Originally Posted by Manc
Boydy died in the night.
That is all. It is day.
All conversations allowed again, we'll come back for nominations at say 9pm.
Fuck off :DQuote:
Originally Posted by SvN
Can we kill SvN please?
And lose the game? Interesting strategy.
I suppose this is a long shot, but if we have an Undertaker, confirming Offys role could be quite useful information to us.
It could well be a bluff but for now we have to trust it.
It's not worth the gamble.
As a renowned chef I know all about rotten eggs and Mahow absolutely stinks. Get rid.
I really can't get a feel for this game at all. How are we to move forward if we learn nothing from the deaths? Are we not just killing at random? I don't get it.
Some roles can learn from deaths, some roles gain nightly information. It's about striking up conversations with people, either publicly or privately, and collating your information to work out who is good and bad.
Part of the risk is you could be in conversation with an evil player and giving information away to that player about your role, which could put a target on your head for the demon.
If everyone this far has been telling the truth we have the current situation:
3 outsiders made up of -
Recluse - Spikey
Saint - SvN
Drunk - ?
5 townsfolk made up of -
Librarian - Mahow
Chef - Offshore
? - ?
? - Boydy
? - P_3
2 minions made up of -
Baron - ?
? - ?
Imp - ?
Using Offshore's clue that there is 1 pairing of evil people, gives us the following groupings following Boydy the presumed townperson's death:
Grayfox and Niko
Manc and Baz
One thing I don't quite get is that the graphic on page 1 says there's only one outsider, which would be me. Presumably a scenario exists where someone else's role (i.e. a Baron) means that we can have additional outsiders, and Spikey could be telling the truth.
Does the existince of a Baron just mean two random people are assigned additional outsider roles?
One of the possible minions in play is the Baron, which results in 2 additional outsiders.
I keep trying to do a he said she said series of points but getting lost in a circle of confusion.
Offshore (chef) knows 2 bad guys are sitting next to each other. Spikey (recluse) may register as bad, so he could make the pair, equally, maybe doesn't because he doesn't register as evil, or isn't sitting next to someone evil. Offy and Spikey had a pre-existing plan to kill Mahow, before roles were handed out, so either the way the seating plan worked out played into their hands or they came up with that plan. I don't think it was a deliberate plan and am inclined to believe their roles. Mahow says he's the librarian and his knowledge (of a drunk) conflicts with Spikey being the recluse as that would mean there are two outsiders when the game says there is one. Now the guy on the other side of Spikey claims to be the saint, yet another outsider. The added kicker here is if there are three outsiders [does the baron make this possible?], and one of them is the drunk, then that person doesn't know about it and thinks they are someone else?
Nope, I'm lost again.
This is what happens when you don't kill Mahow. Given the bloke is watching videos of this game for fun, he probably knows how to confuse everyone and what I'm seeing now is a mess. Get. Rid.
The idea of the game is to gain information from other players in order to start to deduce the evil team. Day 1 is always a crapshoot because it's mostly a guess. But certain players have roles which can reveal more each night and even with each death.
We're already starting to build a picture now of some of the board and 4 hard claimed roles.
It's always worth killing someone in this game script of a day as there's always that chance of hitting the Imp and it's literally the towns only way of fighting back, unless we have a Slayer in play.
I'm not the only one who watches those videos.Quote:
Originally Posted by Offshore Toon
It's a genuinely great game which is very complex.
Can confirm I'm not evil. @P_3
Are we just waiting for the evening kill now?
Just for the sake of investigating, are you willing to claim a role or maybe even hint towards it? @Manc
No we can nominate and execute someone before the evening kill, using the information we all have.Quote:
Originally Posted by SvN
No, this is the towns time for information gathering. Talking to other players, publicly or privately is the key to this.Quote:
Originally Posted by SvN
Evening nomination/voting phase, yes.Quote:
Originally Posted by SvN
I'm happy to make it earlier if the majority want to, I just wasn't sure how long people would want for private chats.
Someone PM me then, given that I've outed myself as a goodie.